Apr 8, 2021

Northern District of California Holds Plaintiffs Lack Article III Standing to Sue for Profiting Off Their Personal Information Without Consent

On March 1, 2021, Magistrate Judge Laurel Beeler of the Northern District of California dismissed a variety of claims brought against the genealogy website based on the website’s use of individuals’ personal information obtained from school yearbooks. In so doing, Judge Beeler added to the growing body of case law defining what constitutes an injury sufficient to support Article III standing in the context of data privacy class actions and highlighted the potential utility of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (“Section 230”) as a tool defendants can use to defeat privacy-related putative class actions.

The case is Callahan v. Inc., No. 20-cv-08437-LB (N.D. Cal.), and you can read a summation at as well as the details Judge Beeler’s decision at: